Peter |
Member since Oct 2007
Family Guy's characters lacks subtly, (that makes me so mad)... but they occasionally have good episodes. Simpsons on the other hand have been a generation shaping tool. They are the number one thing that has shaped our generation, and have the metaphysical depth to question themselves. They have the intricacy to do the play within the play - see Itchy and Scratchy, the depth to cover The Illiad (Lemon of Troy), mock Politicians (see the episode Ralph is nominated...) but the number one kicker is Sideshow Bob. Every episode with Sideshow Bob has been brilliant, where they parody so many movies, and programs. See The Italian Bob, where they actually kickstarted this discussion... (I Criminali Americani- under heading Plagarismo, featuring a picture of Peter Griffin. Stan is under Plagarismo di Plagarismo; which is hillarious). Family Guy's attempt to mock Simpsons is first a tribute to The Naked Gun, and then an attempt to mock Simpsons.
But the correct order of good Cartoon comedy is Futurama, Simpsons, Robot Chicken, Undergrads, Clone High, Family Guy/South Park, King of the Hill, Mission Hill, Hellboy cartoons, Batman, Ninja Turtles etc, and at the bottom American Dad.
But for those who claimed Simpsons are like Family Guy is missing out, that Bart was created to be the Bad Boy of Simpsons, while Stewie is the Bad Boy of Family Guy.
Peter/Homer
Lois/Marge
Stewie/Bart
Carter/Grandpa
both also share -
Incompetent mayor's...
Frequent guest stars,
Serious Plot Holes in many episodes,
Neighbour who's wife is gone (Ned vs Cleveland)
Neighbourhood bars they fight for.
Chronic Alcoholism in many characters, not just Homer/Peter
3 kids in each family,
numerous car accidents as a result of alcoholism
time spent in jail by many characters,
both families have pet dogs,
both are part of the racial majority within their towns
both attend churches- and episodes have focused around them...
both families own guns, and use them frequently
but these similarities seem to be more done to make their message more poignant, rather than as a means of copying each other...