I think Rupert and Stephenie for sure.

How can Rupert even be on there for Pearl Isles? He was the second juror, not even close to the end and played a terrible game...I don't think any of these people should've won but Kelly definitely fought hard to get through those last few votes so she deserved it most in my opinion...not that Rich didn't...

I second you. I have no idea why Rupert is so loved by Americans. He played an awful game... I do not like him.

rupert was the best survivor the game has ever seen. he definitely was a prick and considered the game his, but quickly admitted to his mistakes after he saw himself. he knew why he was voted out and said he deserved it. but there is no denying that he provided way more nourishment than anyone that has ever participated in survivor. he was the strongest at the challenges by far and that's why they cut him loose in all-stars so early. he is definitely not my favorite survivor, but if he was not voted out he would have won hands down and that's why i believe he belongs on this list.

Best player the game has ever seen?? Come on now...he alienated other players, hoarded the spears, was a control freak, calling Pearl Islands "my island"...he played a terrible game and only barely made second juror...he was likeable and different , yes, but FAR from best player ever...

EVERYONE alienates players to a certain extent. but he had a pretty good alliance with the girls from drake. they all knew they had to get rid of him 'cuz no one could beat him. it has nothing to do with barely making the jury. they knew if he were on the jury he'd vote for a drake to win. name one person from that season that would've beat him out if he made it to the final 2........and as far as hoarding the spears and such........so what? nobody else really showed much of an interest in providing fish anyway. burton knew he could and did help out. he then became the fisherman when rupert was gone.

kelly won most of the final immunities not really a great fight

I hated Rupert. He is in my top 5 most hated players list.(Rupert,Big Tom, Cirie, Parvati, Richard). Amanda, Kelly and Stephanie desaerved to win, but especially Amanda She was the best player ever.

What, no love for Colby? He only lost one immunity and didn't get voted out then because of his good social and mental game to back up his physical game. Nobody has ever dominated every aspect the way Colby has.

your forgetting ozzy