I like Lecy as young Becky and Sarah for older Becky.

I can't stand Sarah Chalke, she is a bad actress, back then anyway.

Both did a really good job but in different ways
Lecy was amazing when she was younger and when she came back
and Sarah was a really awesome person to fill Lecy's place, she's so funny.

I'm a little biased because I never really liked the character of Becky anyway, but I always liked Sarah Chalke better. I'm not sure why but I just liked the way she played the character better.

I kind of agree with Audra. Sarah didn't seem like such a great actress back then but I think Lecy looked way too young to play older Becky.

Lecy Goranson was waaayy better than Sarah Chalke. Becky is by far the most annoying/least funny character on the show...and Lecy Goranson had that wonderful whiny quality that made it work. Sarah Chalke wasn't moody/bitchy enough to be Becky...and girlfriend needed to take at least ONE acting lesson!

Definitely Lecy Goranson...Mainly being biased because that is who I felt familiar with the role of Becky, but also because she seemed so much into the character compared to the generic Sarah Chalke.

Lecy was definetly better. And it never usually works when you have somebody playing a character on a popular show for years and then try to switch the actors. The second actor is usually never able to do it as well as the original one could. Sarah Chalke is a horrible actress anyways.

I think Lecy is better at playing Becky but Sarah Chalke was ok, i absolutley adore her in Scrubs but not so much as Becky....
Lecy just knows the character so well and makes becky more realistic in my eyes. though she never seems to age! she still looks 15 when she comes back lol!