Hannah did tell her mom that it was between two people, Gavin and someone else and Gavin was not the father. We all know she slept with Nick and Eddie but she probably slept with Eddie around the same time as Gavin.. I'm kinda wondering if because of the time frame if Eddie is the father of Sam??

There is no way Sam is Eddie's because he was adiment that Hanna Jane told the father the truth now that he is staying. Plus when her mom came to visit she said that it doesn't matter that 'he's' staying- to keep her mouth shut & marry Big Cat.

good point, after watching the whole series (season 1 and 2 again) i am sticking to Nick as the father no matter what tricks they try to pull!!

i think eddie is the father coz when he went to hannah's door to tell her they shuld tell nick the truth guilt was written all over his voice

I want it to be Nick's but on itunes, a girl swears in one of the reviews that she knows the answer because her cousin is Physical phil. she says its the guy who wanted to start Best Friend Windows. I think its going to be Eddy, but the kid is smart like Nick, so who knows!