We all know how this works. Add one to your favorite character and subtract one from your least favorite. When a character gets down to zero, take them off.
(If I spell it wrong, sorry)

Adrian Monk 10
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 10
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 10
Sharona Fleming 10
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 10

Adrian Monk 10
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 11 (+)
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 10
Sharona Fleming 10
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 9 (-)

Adrian Monk 10
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 11
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 11 +
Sharona Fleming 10
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 8 -

Adrian Monk 10
Natalie Teeger 9 (-)
Lt. Randy Disher 12 (+)
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 11
Sharona Fleming 10
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 8

Adrian Monk 11 (+)
Natalie Teeger 9
Lt. Randy Disher 12
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 11
Sharona Fleming 10
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 7 (-)

who wouldn't pick Monk?!
weirdos!

Adrian Monk 12 (+)
Natalie Teeger 9
Lt. Randy Disher 12
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 11
Sharona Fleming 9 (-)
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 7

Adrian Monk 12
Natalie Teeger 10 (+)
Lt. Randy Disher 12
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 10
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 11
Sharona Fleming 8 (-)
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 7

Adrian Monk 12
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 12
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 9 (-)
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 12 (+)
Sharona Fleming 8
Benjamin "Benjy" Fleming 7

Adrian Monk 12
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 13 (+)
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 9
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 12
Sharona Fleming 7 (-) she abandoned Monk!!
Benjamin "Bengy Fleming 7

Adrian Monk 12
Natalie Teeger 10
Lt. Randy Disher 14 (+) He's so clueless it's funny
Captain Leland Stottlemeyer 9
Julie Teeger 10
Dr. Charles Kroger 12
Sharona Fleming 7
Benjamin "Bengy Fleming 6 (-) Julie's more entertaining